How to Choose a Web Design Company: 8 Questions to Ask

Every portfolio looks good. Eight questions that show whether a web design company can make your site work, on time, with your team.

Choosing a web design company is hard when every portfolio looks good. A portfolio shows that they can make something attractive. It does not show whether they can make your site work, on time, with your team. These eight questions get you to that part.

The short answer

  1. What should the site do for our business, and how will we know it worked?
  2. Who will actually work on our project?
  3. Who writes the content?
  4. What is in the price, and what is not?
  5. How do you protect the search traffic we already have?
  6. Which platform will you build on, and can our team edit it?
  7. What happens after launch?
  8. Can we talk to a past client?

1. What should the site do for our business?

A good company asks this before it shows you a single design. The answer should be something you can count: inquiries, bookings, sign-ups, sales calls booked. If the first meeting is all about colors and inspiration, the site will look good and nobody will know whether it worked.

2. Who will actually work on our project?

Many web design companies bring in freelancers for design, development or copy. That works fine as long as your feedback reaches the people doing the work. Ask who handles each part and how they stay in touch with each other. If every message goes through one account manager who passes it on to people you never hear from, details get lost along the way, like a game of telephone.

3. Who writes the content?

This is where most projects run late. If the quote does not say who writes the copy, assume it is you. Ask whether they edit what you send, write it from scratch, or only place it on the page. If your site needs a second language, ask who writes that one too, and whether that person reads the market it is for.

4. What is in the price, and what is not?

Two quotes can differ by a lot because they cover different work. Look for discovery, content, design, build, SEO, testing, training and support after launch, and see which ones are missing. Fixed prices against a written scope are easier to compare than hourly rates, and easier to hold to.

If the work is billed by the hour, treat the estimate as a starting point and expect to pay more than quoted. People work faster or slower than planned, and hours can be spent without the goal being reached. We have seen this again and again, especially with developers hired overseas by the hour. For the sake of your own cash flow, ask whether there is a cap on the hours and what happens when it is reached.

5. How do you protect the search traffic we already have?

If your current site gets visits from Google, a redesign can lose them. A careful company will ask for access to Search Console, list the pages that bring traffic, and map every old URL to a new one before launch. If the answer is vague, read our guide on how to redesign a website without losing SEO before you sign.

6. Which platform will you build on, and can our team edit it?

Ask who will change a headline or add a page six months from now. If the answer is always the agency, you are buying a maintenance contract along with the site. Ask to see the editor on a past project.

Then make sure you own everything. We have met too many companies that lost touch with their last agency, heard nothing back, or were asked to pay extra just to get access to their own site. Spare yourself that. Ask for the passwords and keys to the domain, hosting, CMS, analytics and code, even the parts you do not fully understand yet, and keep them somewhere safe.

7. What happens after launch?

Real users find things that internal reviews miss. Ask how long fixes are included after launch, how small changes are billed, and whether they check analytics and forms after launch. The first few weeks are when real customers start using the site and small problems show up, so it helps to know who you can call.

8. Can we talk to a past client?

Case studies are written by the agency. A ten-minute call with a past client tells you how they handle feedback, deadlines and problems. Ask for a client whose project was like yours in size, rather than their most famous one.

Signs to slow down

  • They quote before asking what the site needs to do
  • Nobody can tell you who writes the content
  • The price has no written scope behind it
  • They have never asked about your current traffic

Before you contact anyone

Write down what is not working now, what a good result looks like, and your budget range. It makes every first call shorter and every quote easier to compare. Our website redesign RFP template walks through what to put in a brief. If you need a team that works in English in Tokyo, this guide covers what to check.

Not sure what your site needs yet?

Start with our free website diagnostic. It shows what is holding the site back before you talk to anyone. When you are ready, see how we run website design projects.

Hitomi Abiko

Author

Hitomi Abiko

Hitomi Abiko is co-founder and CEO of Skydea, a web and app design agency in Tokyo and Boston. A UX designer turned founder, she writes about the places where design, technology, and business collide, and what that means for the companies building in that space.

Read More